Comments on: Cardio vs HIIT vs Weights: Rebooting Our Research https://live-beibosport.com/blog/cardio-vs-hiit-vs-weights-rebooting-our-research/ Level up your life, every single day. Mon, 25 Apr 2022 16:37:44 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4 By: Fala22 https://live-beibosport.com/blog/cardio-vs-hiit-vs-weights-rebooting-our-research/comment-page-3/#comment-5460037 Mon, 25 Apr 2022 16:37:44 +0000 https://live-beibosport.com/?p=944141#comment-5460037 There are two issues I have with this article and even the Anthony Mychal’s paper on HIIT.

1. The time: according to most experts on HIIT, one definitely should not be doing HIIT for 40-45 minutes. That’s questionable, and is refuted as inauthentic HIIT. The maximum anyone should doing it is 30mins. This being that the intensity would be too much for 40-45 mins. So, I question any study that uses the time. Although Mychal talks about the use of HIIT for 20 minutes, likely as a hypothetical, not being as great as aerobics. The issue is those who HIIT well, seem to recognise that people can go beyond what can be done with aerobics.

2. The study in regards to real world application is laughable. Why in the world would anyone throw inactive and overweight people into HIIT, and expect it to be approachable. Authentic HIIT is tough on athletes who are conditioned and healthier. People are supposed to work up to HIIT, likely using aerobic exercises first, and then going into anaerobic. After looking at who they used for that study, I’m going for a hard, “No” on that study. Definitely don’t do authentic HIIT without working up to it first. This helps avoid injury and worse.

Other than that, I’m not seeing evidence that aerobics is better at all than HIIT or the reverse. I personally prefer to do my own inauthentic version of HIIT(I’m working up to the authentic version), because unlike what Mychal claims, my time is better spent doing other things a lot of times and don’t want to be doing cardio longer than necessary. Plus, I’ve noticed that when I do things close the HIIT approach, I drop weight, after dropping water weight, faster. For whatever reason, I get results. But I think in general there will also be hype, typically has been and typically will be. Based on the HIIT experts, and research on about Aerobic vs Anaerobic exercise, I’m not sure it really matters. Although, I’m seeing that anaerobic leans more towards weight loss, and aerobic leans toward endurance, but overall, they both seem to have the same outcome in ways.

So, I think it’s best to wait and see what comes out of more studies, and also my hope is that researchers are more consistent in how they do their research. If HIIT was primarily done on stationary bikes, then peer review studies should aim for that same approach. And from what I’m seeing there are some people using other exercises which don’t actually work for HIIT. And I’m seeing improper time approaches, meaning 30mins and under should be used for the study.

Also, I would like to see researchers try pushing the two types, meaning although 300 calories/burned is used for HIIT, to say 2-3 days week means 900 calories/burned compared to 200 calories/burned with traditional cardio 7 days a week, means 1,400 calories a week. The question is, why is HIIT limited to 300 calories? There are cases as high as 600 calories in one session. So, again, by working up to the intensity necessary, one can burn up to 1,800 a week with HIIT. With traditional cardio, the push to burn more calories a week seems easier since, if someone decided to, they could push up their effort, but my understanding is that 1 hour of cardio is 250-300 calories when done at moderate effort, could be wrong. Assuming you are doing it both correctly and thereby safely. By comparing authentic HIIT to traditional aerobics, we can better gauge the two.

]]>
By: Raven https://live-beibosport.com/blog/cardio-vs-hiit-vs-weights-rebooting-our-research/comment-page-3/#comment-5459967 Mon, 25 Apr 2022 13:57:31 +0000 https://live-beibosport.com/?p=944141#comment-5459967 So, here’s where I question the debate between HIIT and Cardio:

1) From what I’m seeing in this article, authentic HIIT was likely not performed in one of the studies cited. Normally, experts on HIIT would tell you that 40 to 45 minutes, is too long for HIIT and if you can perform that long, you aren’t doing it correctly. So, exactly how were they doing the exercise that it’s was that long? Which says to me that people don’t actually know how beneficial HIIT is because the studies that seem to counter it aren’t making sure to study the exercise in its proper form. With this said, it just comes down to people choosing whichever one they want to do. Personally, I prefer HIIT over traditional cardio, even though HIIT likely doesn’t produce significant improvements compared to TC.

2) The other study about real world application was laughable, why in the world would anyone give authentic HIIT to overweight, inactive people and expect it to work? Normally HIIT is something you have to work up to., of course they wouldn’t be able to handle it. Even highly trained athletes are challenged by authentic HIIT. So, the moral of this story is progress. People should start simple and work their way up, don’t jump into HIIT. The progress is also key to avoiding injury.

Overall, there just doesn’t seem to be enough evidence to say HIIT is or isn’t more beneficial, which means things have to be more anecdotal than scientific, until there is an improvement in consistency, regarding how HIIT is compared to TC. Researchers really need to make sure they are using authentic HIIT, which should not be more 30 minutes.

]]>
By: Fala22 https://live-beibosport.com/blog/cardio-vs-hiit-vs-weights-rebooting-our-research/comment-page-3/#comment-5460032 Mon, 25 Apr 2022 12:25:47 +0000 https://live-beibosport.com/?p=944141#comment-5460032 In reply to Ben Stark.

“ Finally, the benefits of HIT/ Tabata workouts are in my mind questionable. First, like the post said, most people really don’t push themselves hard enough. Second, even in the research there are some big confounding factors. For example, the original Tabata studies used speed skaters. Yes, they did the Tabata workout but they also spent about 5-9 hours a week doing skill drills for skating. These drills probably put their heart rates in the low zone 2 for most of that time. So what they received was 10 hours a week of low level aerobic training with maybe 1 to 1 1/2 hours a week of sprints. That will improve anyone’s endurance. Endurance athletes have been successful using programs that look like that for years.”

Well, I disagree, I would say it’s the opposite in my opinion, I’m not sure about Tabatha, but what I do know is that the HIIT studies focus more on stationary bike usage or running. Which means, a lot of the “HIIT” programs out there aren’t authentic. With this a said, one can push their caloric burn above 300 with HIIT, making HIIT just as effective, but likely not significantly more.

]]>
By: Cardio Confusion: How Much HIIT is Too Much? | Wendy Fitness Coaching https://live-beibosport.com/blog/cardio-vs-hiit-vs-weights-rebooting-our-research/comment-page-3/#comment-5194300 Wed, 16 Jun 2021 10:36:15 +0000 https://live-beibosport.com/?p=944141#comment-5194300 […] Nerd Fitness: Cardio vs HIIT vs Weights: Rebooting Our Research […]

]]>
By: 3 HIIT Workouts for Beginners: Start Interval Training and Sprint Running! – Pelberry https://live-beibosport.com/blog/cardio-vs-hiit-vs-weights-rebooting-our-research/comment-page-3/#comment-5082198 Mon, 25 Jan 2021 08:28:02 +0000 https://live-beibosport.com/?p=944141#comment-5082198 […] deserves praise, but exercise, in general, deserves praise. As we discussed in our “Cardio vs HIIT vs Weights” post, all three forms of training have their place, and the best one for you is the one you […]

]]>
By: 3 HIIT Workouts for Beginners: Start Interval Training and Sprint Running! - Fitness, Health and Weight Loss News https://live-beibosport.com/blog/cardio-vs-hiit-vs-weights-rebooting-our-research/comment-page-3/#comment-5082090 Sun, 24 Jan 2021 23:19:54 +0000 https://live-beibosport.com/?p=944141#comment-5082090 […] deserves praise, but exercise, in general, deserves praise. As we discussed in our “Cardio vs HIIT vs Weights” post, all three forms of training have their place, and the best one for you is the one you […]

]]>
By: Beginner HIIT Workouts: 3 Running & Interval Training Routines – Southern Red's Exercise Bike Reviews & News https://live-beibosport.com/blog/cardio-vs-hiit-vs-weights-rebooting-our-research/comment-page-3/#comment-5039559 Tue, 01 Dec 2020 04:47:47 +0000 https://live-beibosport.com/?p=944141#comment-5039559 […] deserves praise, but exercise in general deserves praise. As we discussed in our “Cardio vs HIIT vs Weights” post, all three forms of training have their place, and the best one for you is the one you […]

]]>
By: 3 HIIT Workouts for Beginners: Start Interval Training and Sprint Running! – Personal Development https://live-beibosport.com/blog/cardio-vs-hiit-vs-weights-rebooting-our-research/comment-page-3/#comment-5039512 Tue, 01 Dec 2020 03:30:40 +0000 https://live-beibosport.com/?p=944141#comment-5039512 […] deserves praise, but exercise in general deserves praise. As we discussed in our “Cardio vs HIIT vs Weights” post, all three forms of training have their place, and the best one for you is the one you […]

]]>
By: Nathan Allen Yoder https://live-beibosport.com/blog/cardio-vs-hiit-vs-weights-rebooting-our-research/comment-page-3/#comment-5014794 Tue, 20 Oct 2020 19:30:40 +0000 https://live-beibosport.com/?p=944141#comment-5014794 In reply to Tony Giovannetti.

you are stupid and opinion based….TONY

]]>
By: 3 HIIT Workouts for Beginners: Start Interval Training and Sprint Running! - Your Summer Body Store https://live-beibosport.com/blog/cardio-vs-hiit-vs-weights-rebooting-our-research/comment-page-3/#comment-4955282 Sat, 18 Jul 2020 12:40:05 +0000 https://live-beibosport.com/?p=944141#comment-4955282 […] deserves praise, but exercise in general deserves praise. As we discussed in our “Cardio vs HIIT vs Weights” post, all three forms of training have their place, and the best one for you is the one you […]

]]>